| Platinum | 18Seventy Brewing Co. |
| Gold | Sacred Slice LLC |
| Silver | Luigis Pizza |
| Bronze | Gold Dust Pizza Express |
| Top Pick | Donatello's Take & Bake Pizza |
| Top Pick | Jack's Pizza Cafe |
| Top Pick | Little Caesars Pizza |
| Top Pick | Michael's Pizza Bar and Grill |
| Top Pick | Mike's Grillhouse |
| Top Pick | Mountain Mike's Pizza |
| Galletto Ristorante | |
| Verona's Cucina Italiana |